| Wireless LAN Security |
|
Wireless LANs
(WLANs) extend and leverage the ubiquity of Ethernet networks and
the internet. WLANs also extend the plug-and play nature of Ethernet
to locations where wiring may be difficult, impractical, or expensive.
They also enable mobility, allowing users to retain access to corporate
resources when in meetings or otherwise on the move.
So why, then, haven't enterprises fully embraced WLANs as an intrinsic
part of their IT infrastructures? The primary obstacle has been concerns surrounding
security.
WLAN signals are transmitted via radio waves. Because signals are
airborne and do not require line of sight to reach their destinations, they have
no physical barriers to protect them from outsiders. Consequently, intruders
can intercept the signals of non-secure access points (APs) from outside a building
using "war-driving" and "war-chalking" methods, exposing the enterprise's confidential
resources. The insertion of "rogue" APs malicious or otherwise can also create
vulnerabilities.
Wired Equivalent Privacy (WEP), the primary security mechanism
that has long shipped with most WLAN products, has proven insufficient to protect
networks against unauthorized access, session hijacking, eavesdropping, and other
threats. Roaming is another issue: WLAN users cannot generally roam between IP
subnets without re-authenticating themselves to the network. And inter-subnet
roaming may simply not work in some multi-vendor WLAN environments.
Not surprisingly, enterprises have not taken these threats sitting
down. They have adopted several solutions to their security concerns, including
the following:
- DMZ isolation. This approach uses virtual LANs (VLANs) to
segregate the WLAN traffic and connect WLAN users to certain
enterprise servers in a DMZ area outside the corporate firewall.
This prevents unauthorized users from using the corporate WLAN
for Internet access and protects the corporate LAN.
- RF isolation. This approach attempts to isolate the WLAN radio
signals from the outside world. With a high-gain directional
antenna, outsiders can gain unauthorized access to a WLAN from
many miles away. One way to combat this threat is to provide
a physical barrier that RF signals cannot penetrate to simulate
a secure zone.
- Another method of blocking unauthorized outsiders from taking
advantage of the open-air availability of the signal is to surround
the perimeter of the corporate grounds with APs that are not
connected to the internal network. An outsider is blocked from
seeing the internal WLAN because the outside APs operate at the
same frequency as the internal ones and offer greater signal
strength to the outsider. In effect, the external WLAN jams the
internal signal for the outsider. The disadvantages of this approach
are that it is expensive and is not 100% effective.
- Proprietary WLANs. Some WLAN vendors have developed their
own security solutions. Most are vaguely standards-based, but
cannot interoperate with other vendors solutions. Customers
are thus locked in a single-vendor scenario, which comes with
a high price tag and a complete dependence on the vendors
strategy and development cycle. Often the intelligence in these
solutions is implemented in the APs, complicating management,
increasing costs, and at times requiring hardware upgrades to
support new features if processing power is insufficient to handle
the added capabilities. Clearly, these stopgap approaches incur
a total cost of ownership penalty and are difficult to evolve.
- IP virtual private networks (VPNs). IP VPNs were developed
to initially meet the needs of secure remote access over the
Internet. Enterprises have favored this technology for adding
security to WLAN deployments either by leveraging their investments
in secure IP services gateways, or by deploying additional VPN
units closer to the WLAN APs.
IP VPN-based wireless security is platform- and radio technology-agnostic;
the client system establishes a connection to the network via the WLAN, and the
VPN takes over from there. Users trying to access the network via the WLAN are
first authenticated by the WLAN network and then by the VPN server (exactly as
if they were accessing the enterprise across the Internet). Their information
is encrypted, and all communication is logged by the VPN system. This approach
solves many enterprise WLAN security challenges.
These approaches to securing WLANs solve some, but not all, elements
of the security conundrum. What works best is the use of solid WLAN standards
combined with a WLAN architecture that is functional, secure, and manageable. |